Cover : PRACTICAL GUIDE: Your Rights in Police Custody

PRACTICAL GUIDE: Your Rights in Police Custody

All too often in my day-to-day practice, I find that people are not aware of the rights they have in police custody (garde à vue). This causes unnecessary stress and apprehension for the person held in custody and for their loved ones. Although their rights must be notified to them, usually quickly, at the start of custody, the person in custody is very often in shock after their arrest, stunned and therefore less able to take in what they are told.

Conditions:

There must be plausible grounds to suspect that you have committed or attempted to commit a crime or offence punishable by imprisonment.

The decision to place you in police custody must be taken by a criminal investigation officer (officier de police judiciaire, OPJ), who may be a police officer or a gendarme.

A person suspected of an offence may also be questioned on a voluntary basis (audition libre).

Duration:

Police custody may initially last 24 hours.

This period may be shortened or extended. If the offence concerned is punishable by at least 1 year's imprisonment, custody may be extended to up to 48 hours.

For certain offences (drug trafficking, organised crime, terrorism, etc.), police custody may last up to 72, 96 or 144 hours.

In principle, police custody starts from the time of arrest, including when the person is placed in a sobering-up cell.

Rights of the person in police custody:

Notification of rights

The person in police custody must be informed immediately by the criminal investigation officer, in a language they understand, of all their rights:

Always make a point of rereading your statements before signing them, as your signature binds you and means that you fully approve what the officer has written. If you consider that your words have been distorted, you can ask the officer to amend them and, if they refuse, you have the right not to sign. This refusal will have no consequences other than allowing you to challenge what was written at a later stage.

Right to a lawyer

If the person in custody asks for a lawyer, their first interview cannot begin without the lawyer being present, unless it relates solely to their identity.

Do not hesitate to use your right to silence and refuse to answer questions until your lawyer is present. It is your right, and a judge cannot hold it against you.

In certain cases, however, the judicial officer in charge of the case (judge or prosecutor) may authorise an immediate interview.

On arrival, the lawyer may speak with their client for 30 minutes. However, the lawyer has access to only very limited information: simply the notification of rights and any medical certificate.

The lawyer may attend all interviews and take notes. At the end of each interview, the lawyer may ask questions or make written observations, which will be added to the case file.

The argument that having a lawyer present will slow your case down and that you will be released much later is misleading. Once contacted by the criminal investigation officer, the lawyer has two hours to arrive. Moreover, weigh up the costs and benefits carefully: the presence of a lawyer is a guarantee that your rights will be respected and only extends police custody by 30 minutes (the length of the consultation).

If you do not know a lawyer, you can have a duty lawyer (avocat commis d'office) whose fees are paid by the State.

Right to a doctor

This examination can establish whether you are medically fit to be held in police custody.

If you require urgent treatment (for example, insulin for diabetics), the doctor may request that you be taken to the forensic medical unit (unité médico-judiciaire) for emergency treatment.

It can also allow any marks from a “heavy-handed” arrest to be examined and recorded.

Right to have someone informed

Someone, yes, but not just anyone.

It is usually the criminal investigation officer who makes this call for you. Direct communication between the person in custody and a loved one (by telephone, in writing or face to face) may be authorised if it does not harm the investigation.

You can have the following informed: your employer, anyone you usually live with, or a member of your family (father, mother, child, brother or sister).

Right to an interpreter

Whatever your language, you are entitled to an interpreter, who must translate your words faithfully.

Right to remain silent

Except as regards your identity, it is your right: you can decide to remain silent at any time.

This does not prevent the officer from questioning you.

Be aware that if you refuse to answer questions, police custody will probably be extended to its maximum.

Searches

Police officers or gendarmes of the same sex may carry out the following on the person in police custody:

Only a doctor may carry out a body search involving an intimate examination.

Outcomes of police custody

You may:

In all cases, the presence of a lawyer reassures, calms and helps to ensure that all your rights are effectively upheld.

We hope you have found this article useful. The practice is available both to discuss your personal situation and to work with you to find practical and effective answers to your problem. Please do not hesitate to contact us.

Recent publications